West Bank – Israel is moving forward with plans to build more than 1,000 homes in two small isolated Jewish settlements deep in the West Bank, a spokesman said Thursday, as Palestinian officials complained that Israel is undercutting U.S. peace efforts at a sensitive time.
Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email
The settlements to be expanded, Itamar and Bruchin, are located in an area of the West Bank that would not be part of Israel in any foreseeable partition deal with the Palestinians. The building plans, which still need final approval, would increase the number of homes in both settlements far beyond any needs for accommodating natural population growth.
The Israeli anti-settlement group Peace Now initially reported the proposed expansions of the two settlements, a decision later confirmed by Guy Inbar, a spokesman for Israel’s Defense Ministry, which helps oversee settlement policy. He said the plans were advanced in the past two weeks.
The construction plans were given preliminary approval last year and still require official endorsement following public appeals.
Israeli settlement building lies at the heart of the current impasse over restarting negotiations on the terms of a Palestinian state alongside Israel. Such talks broke down nearly five years ago, and U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry has shuttled between the two sides in recent months to bring them back to the table, so far to no avail.
The Palestinians want a state in the West Bank, Gaza and east Jerusalem, lands Israel captured in 1967. Before going to talks, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas wants Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to recognize Israel’s pre-1967 line as a starting point or promise to stop building in settlements. The Israeli leader has refused to do either, saying all issues should be discussed in negotiations.
Moving ahead with plans to expand isolated settlements in the heartland of the West Bank is an “Israeli escalation,” Nimr Hamad, an Abbas adviser, said Thursday.
“It’s not the first time that they do this to challenge and embarrass the American administration,” he said. “The Palestinian position is clear. The settlement activities are illegal.”
Senior Israeli government officials were traveling with Netanyahu in Poland and not immediately available for comment. An official in Netanyahu’s office said he was not authorized to comment on the record.
More than 550,000 Israelis live in dozens of settlements in the West Bank and east Jerusalem, a majority in larger communities close to Israel’s pre-1967 frontier. In addition, the West Bank is dotted with smaller settlements, such as Bruchin and Itamar, as well as dozens of outposts not formally sanctioned by the government that would likely have to be dismantled in any partition deal.
Kerry has been searching for a formula that would bring Israel and the Palestinians back to the negotiating table. It is expected to include a slowdown in settlement construction, security guarantees to Israel and economic incentives to the Palestinians.
Kerry has urged both sides to avoid provocative actions that could hurt the negotiating climate. There was no immediate U.S. comment Thursday.
The international community considers Israeli settlements on war-won lands illegal or illegitimate.
Hagit Ofran of Peace Now, an anti-settlement watchdog group, said the new plans included construction of 1,000 homes, and retroactive approval of 200 existing homes. She said construction could begin in about a year.
Bruchin, which currently has 52 apartments, started out as an unauthorized settlement outpost, one of dozens settlers put up since the 1990s with the declared aim of preventing the establishment of a Palestinian state. A year ago, the government began the process of retroactively legalizing Bruchin, said Ofran. Bruchin is to have a total of 550 homes.
In Itamar, the planners retroactively legalized 137 homes built without permits and decided to add another 538, for a total of 675, Ofran said. Itamar also serves as a “mother settlement” for several outposts.
The latest plan exposes the Netanyahu’s government’s intentions, Ofran said. “While he is saying he is ready for peace and two states, he is acting to prevent it on the ground,” she said.
Keep building and securing the holy land. The Jewish people should be focussed on two things, building Israel and being united. What many people on the extremes of religeon and secularism don’t understand is that it is imperative to our security to be united no matter what our beliefs from both a religous and a strategic standpoint. People on the far left overlook the strategic importance of a united Jewish people to the security of Israel. To many people on the right think the abishter is looking for us to fulfill the minutia of religeon even at the expense of our relations with our brothers and sisters; to the extent that many will even support our enemies. The abishter can forgive an aveira beween man and Him with ease but to forgive the hatred and fighting betweeen the extremes among us, I’m afraid will not happen. Many people here, including ones who have called me antisemite, christian, cholent and news paper Jew, etc etc will hopefully someday mature and realize what’s really important to the abishter. Many of us who complain about charedim etc fully appreciate the value of practicing and do practice the details and stringency of yiddishkeit but we also realize that this is the minutia and the abishter looks for something much deeper than that.
I hope this is not a silly question. Is there a shortage of homes in Israel?
They themselves decided to give Israel a free hand to actually go ahead with building, because they gave up their cruel game of refusing to speak to Israel in peace negotiations EVEN WHEN THE FREEZE WAS IN PROGRESS, and later too, which kept Israel waiting, could be even for ever, and this was a cruel game, but it kept Israel unsure what to do and when. But when they went to the UN, and UN gave them what they wanted, which was a state, this completely let Israel off the hook.
So then, can anyone tell me if there is a housing shortage in Israel?