Jewish Murder Victims Identified: Young Mother And Yeshiva Student Among Civilian Casualties

Law enforcement gathers near the scene following reports of gunfire, Tuesday, Dec. 10, 2019, in Jersey City, N.J. AP Photo/Eduardo Munoz Alvarez)

JERSEY CITY (VINnews) — The names of two of the murder victims in today’s shooting in Jersey City have been cleared for release.

The names are:

Moshe Hersh Deutch, 24, son of Sholom Deutch of Williamsburg

Leah Mindel Ferentz, 33. She was the wife of Moshe Dovid Ferentz, and the daughter of Binyomin Hersh Greenfeld.  Leah and her husband yb”lct were co-owners of the store.

These 2 victims were 2 out of 3 civilian casualties that were found in the JC Kosher Supermarket, where the perps were shooting from. The perps themselves were also killed on location.

The supermarket was the second of two locations involved in the shooting attack. The incident began with a shooting in Bayview Cemetery, with a police officer being shot. After the shooters were pursued by the police, they then fled to the store, from where they continued shooting.

Initially the incident was understood to be a criminal investigation gone awry, with the shooters onky randomly ending up in the supermarket. However Jersey City mayor Steve Fulop has since tweeted that the location was targeted.

These 2 victims are among 6 total deaths that occured. The total amount of casualties is 6, with 2 of them being the perps, 3 being civilians, and 1 police offier.

The slain officer, Detective Joseph Seals, 40, was credited by his superiors with having led the department in the number of illegal guns removed from the streets in recent years, and might have been trying to stop an incident involving such weapons when he was cut down by gunfire that erupted near a cemetery, authorities said.

Two other officers were wounded but were later released from the hospital, authorities said.

The bullets started flying early in the afternoon in the city of about 270,000 people, situated across the Hudson River from New York City. Seals, who worked for a unit called Cease Fire, was shot around 12:30 p.m. The gunmen then drove a stolen rental van to another part of the city and engaged police in a lengthy shootout.

Kelly said when police responded to the area of the kosher store, officers “were immediately engaged by high-power rifle fire.”

A video shot by a witness shows a police officer on the ground by a car, apparently wounded. Another officer goes to him, helps him up and the two run around a corner as gunshots ring out. Seconds later, as a police cruiser pulls up in front of the store, about a dozen shots are heard in rapid succession.

“Our officers were under fire for hours,” the chief said.

Inside the grocery store, police found the bodies of who they believed were the two gunmen and three other people who apparently happened to be there when the assailants rushed in, authorities said. Police said they were confident the bystanders were shot by the gunmen and not by police.

The kosher grocery is a central fixture in a growing community of Orthodox Jews who have been moving to Jersey City in recent years.

Chabad Rabbi Moshe Schapiro, who shops at the kosher store and attends a synagogue next door, said he spoke with the store owner, Moishe Ferencz.

“He told me he had just walked out of the store into the synagogue not five feet away just before this happened, and then he couldn’t get back for hours,” Schapiro said. “His wife was inside the store. He said, ‘I hope my wife is safe.’”

The names of the victims inside the store were not immediately released, pending notification of relatives.

City Public Safety Director James Shea said earlier Tuesday that authorities believe the bloodshed was not an act of terrorism but that it was still under investigation.

The shooting spread fear through the neighborhood, and the nearby Sacred Heart School was put on lockdown as a precaution.

SWAT teams, state police and federal agents converged on the scene, and police blocked off the area, which in addition to the school and supermarket included a hair salon and other shops. Dozens of bystanders pressed against the police barrier to capture the action on their cellphones, some whooping when bursts of fire could be heard.

Video shot by residents recorded loud volleys of gunfire reverberating along one of the city’s main streets and showed a long line of law enforcement officers pointing guns as they advanced, yelling to bystanders, “Clear the street! Get out of the way!”

“It’s like firecrackers going off,” said Andy Patel, who works at a liquor store about three blocks away. “They were shooting like crazy. … The cops were clearing everyone off the streets.”

Police also removed what they described as a possible “incendiary device” from the rental vehicle and sent it for examination by a bomb squad. The results of that examination were not available Tuesday evening.

Seals had been on the Jersey City Police Department since 2006. In addition to his work with the illegal guns unit, he was cited for heroism in a Christmas Eve 2008 incident in which he and another officer burst through the window of a home and stopped a sexual assault that was being carried out against a 41-year-old woman.

Seventh grader Zamir Butler said his class was coming back inside from the playground at Sacred Heart, which sits across the street from the grocery store, when he heard the shots. At first he thought they were thunder, since it had rained earlier.

“Everybody was running up the stairs to get to safety in the classroom,” he said. “A few of the kids were crying. They told us to stay behind the wall and stay down.”

Follow VosIzNeias For Breaking News Updates is here to help you manage your home without the stress. Go to for recipes, menu planners, kids' activities, and more.


  1. Mr. Fulop, himself a grandson of Holocaust survivors and a graduate of yeshivas, said in an interview. “It’s not the best way to endear yourself to the community, and there’s been a lot of pushback.”

    I blame this self hating Jewish Mayor, Steven Fulop for these thugs targeting davka the Frum community. If the Mayor himself hates the Yidden, what do you expect from the criminals? I see Mr. Fulop learnt very well from his idol, Eric Holder, how to sow the seeds of division. The incompetent Fulop should resign in disgrace.

  2. I’m glad that they have no indication that there aren’t any further threats, as if they had any indication that there was a threat in the first place.

    What a stupid thing to say!

    • This is a standard reply which law enforcement always makes when the coast is clear and is in no way stupid, but very necessary. What’s stupid is to be an over-chuchem and call it stupid. Saying that there’s no indication of any further threats doesn’t imply that there were any prior indications. This is not a litmus in Gomorah!

      Learn better English!

  3. The cops are coward’s, This was a botched up police scene, 4 hours? police sheriff FBI SWAT 100’s of personal and are waiting 4 hours outside, that’s their training? To give those bums to shoot everyone in the store, SWAT should have stormed that place.

  4. Very easy to blame the police. I think they heroically tried multiple times to barge in and even got injured. They didnt know if they had explosives (as they feared) and yet tried anyway. Keep in mind that these thugs executed all nebech right away. They were given no chance…

    • Yu r correct. Tre to remember
      1 Try have families to go home too
      2. With out them donut eaters we’d be a lot worse off
      3. All you brave basement hiding fools not one of you would walk into a gun fight

  5. I live in a small Midwest community where I can spend months at a time without seeing another Frum Jew if I don’t make it to shul. That said, the one comment I have yet to see here is: Hamakom Yenachem es Chevlai Tzion V’Yerushalayim. May Hashem comfort all of this affected by this tragedy. And maybe we can stop the bickering for just a second to remember them???? (And please, don’t bother correcting my public school transliteration. It’s the best I can do and flaming won’t help.)

  6. i agree with Stepens; the SWAT team had an armored vehicle, which is comparable to a small tank. The bullets from those crazy animals inside the shop, would have bounced off the armor plating of the SWAT vehicle. Therefore, why did it take them four hours to utilize that vehicle, and storm the place? I think that they couldn’t make a decision. Years ago, in Philadelphia, when there was a crazy group, engaging in sniper fire against the law enforcement, the cops used a helicopter, and dropped a bomb on the building, blowing those lunatics to pieces.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here